Bank Negara raises the bar for Financial Services Providers in Treatment of Financial Consumers

On 27 March 2024, Bank Negara Malaysia (“BNM”) issued the revised Policy Document on Fair Treatment of Financial Consumers (“the Revised Policy Document”). The Revised Policy Document supersedes a policy document by the same name on 6 November 2019 (BNM/RH/PD/028-103) (“the Superseded Policy Document”).
 
The Revised Policy Document came into effect on 27 March 2024 except for the following paragraphs which will come into effect on 1 April 2025: 
  1. paragraph 8.1(g) - responsibility to implement measure to deliver Outcome 7: Fair and equitable treatment of vulnerable consumers; 

  2. paragraph 10.3(f) - responsibility of senior management to ensure that measures taken to embed fair treatment of financial consumers into all stages of the product life cycle adheres to the requirements under paragraphs 16.1 to 16.28; 

  3. paragraph 10.3(g) - responsibility of senior management to establish and maintain appropriate policies, processes and accountability structures that assist staff, representatives and agents to meet the needs of vulnerable customers when carrying out their roles; 

  4. paragraph 10.4 - requirement that measures taken to implement paragraph 10.3(g) should promote a business culture that recognises that existing and prospective customers may or are already facing vulnerabilities, and reward good behaviour and actions by staff, representatives and agents who are able to respond effectively to the specific needs of vulnerable consumers; and 

  5. paragraphs 16.1 to 16.28 - standards and guidance comprised in Principle 7 that ensure fair and equitable treatment of vulnerable consumers. 
As in the case of the Superseded Policy Document, the Revised Policy Document applies to the following financial services providers (severally “FSP” and collectively “FSPs”): 
  1. a licensed bank;
  2. a licensed Islamic bank;
  3. a licensed insurer;
  4. a licensed takaful operator;
  5. a prescribed development financial institution;
  6. an approved issuer of a designated payment instrument;
  7. an approved issuer of a designated Islamic payment instrument;
  8. an approved insurance broker;
  9. an approved takaful broker;
  10. an approved financial adviser; and
  11. an approved Islamic financial adviser. 
This article provides a summary of the main changes introduced under the Revised Policy Document.
 
Extension of scope
 
Among others, the Superseded Policy Document requires FSPs to embed a culture that treats financial consumers fairly and consider the interests of such consumers as part of the FSPs’ business strategies and operations. The Revised Policy Document extends these requirements to include specific requirements for FSPs to consider and respond to the interests and needs of vulnerable consumers in conducting its business and operations, and to provide appropriate support to vulnerable consumers. These new requirements are principally set out in the new Principle 7 of the Revised Policy Document.
 
Definitions
 
The following new definitions have been introduced in the Revised Policy Document: 
  1. persons with disabilities” has the same meaning assigned to it in the Persons with Disabilities Act 2008; and 

  2. vulnerable consumer” refers to a financial consumer who: 
  • may face challenges in accessing financial services or may require assistance to engage in financial services, for example, a person with disabilities or a senior citizen1

  • has a low ability to withstand financial shocks, for example, a person who is overly-indebted or has no savings; 

  • is experiencing or has experienced adverse life events resulting in temporary or long-term financial hardship, for example, natural disasters, temporary loss of income, unemployment, or the death/ total permanent disability of the main breadwinner; or 

  • has an inadequate level of financial literacy or experience in using financial services or products, or poor language skills, for example, a person who only speaks a language other than Bahasa Malaysia or English, is illiterate, or is not digitally savvy. 
The definition of “representatives” and “agents” in the Superseded Policy Document has been amended to include Perlindungan Tenang2 partners and related parties of persons who are “representatives” or “agents” of a FSP.
 
Where a financial consumer is a micro or small business, references to a “financial consumer” for the purposes of the provisions relating to a “vulnerable consumer” shall be construed as a reference to the individual(s) running the business.3
 
New objective relating to vulnerable consumers
 
The Superseded Policy Document sets out six outcomes to be achieved by a FSP. The Revised Policy Document introduces a new Outcome 7 which is to ensure that vulnerable consumers are to be treated fairly and equitably by the FSP and its staff, representatives and agents.
 
Expansion of responsibilities of senior management
 
The responsibilities of the senior management have been expanded to include: 
  1. demonstrate a commitment to fair treatment of vulnerable consumers (paragraph 10.3(d)); 

  2. ensure that engagements by staff with vulnerable consumers adheres to the requirements set out in paragraphs 16.1 to 16.28 of the Revised Policy Document (paragraph 10.3(f)); and 

  3. establish and maintaining appropriate policies, processes and accountability structures that assist staff, representatives and agents to meet the needs of vulnerable consumers when carrying out their roles (paragraph 10.3(g)). 
The measures taken to implement paragraph 10.3(g) above should promote a business culture that recognises that existing and prospective customers may be or are already facing vulnerabilities, and rewards good behaviour and actions by staff, representatives or agents who are able to respond effectively to specific needs of vulnerable consumers (paragraph 10.4).
 
New Principle 7
 
A new Principle 7 (paragraph 16.1 to 16.28) sets out specific requirements and guidance on fair treatment of vulnerable consumers. Among others, a FSP is required to: 
  1. understand the needs of vulnerable consumers and ensure its staff, representatives and agents have the right skills to take appropriate actions throughout the entire product life cycle to be able to deliver fair outcomes to vulnerable consumers; 

  2. assess the needs of vulnerable consumers in its existing financial consumer base and target market, as well as implement appropriate policies and procedures to meet these needs so as to ensure that vulnerable consumers are treated fairly in accordance with the requirements in the Revised Policy Document throughout their engagement and dealings with the FSP. The FSP must also ensure that the policies and procedures are clearly communicated to the relevant staff, representatives and agents so that they are implemented effectively; 

  3. refrain from engaging in predatory practices in their dealings with vulnerable consumers, including sales and marketing practices that exploit vulnerable consumers such as providing misleading information on risks and returns, which could lead to vulnerable consumers buying unsuitable or complex products which are not in line with their needs or financial circumstances; 

  4. exercise due care when adopting artificial intelligence and machine learning in credit assessments and risk underwriting to avoid unfair discrimination, excessive pricing or exclusion of vulnerable consumers from accessing essential financial services and products; 

  5. ensure that relevant information about the needs of vulnerable consumers is properly captured or recorded in a manner that would enable the FSP to meet the needs of such consumers promptly and consistently, and is accessible by staff who may need to refer to such information; 

  6. provide its financial consumers with information that is easily accessible on how they can obtain assistance in the event they encounter sudden life events that places them in vulnerable circumstances, such as the death or permanent disability of the household’s main breadwinner due to illness or accident; 

  7. ensure communication with vulnerable consumers throughout the product life cycle is clear and easily understood by vulnerable consumers; the FSP must periodically test and verify the effectiveness of its communication channels for vulnerable consumers and adapt appropriately, where necessary, to ensure the communication channels remain accessible to vulnerable consumers throughout the product life cycle. The FSP must also ensure that vulnerable consumers are made aware of the different communication channels available to enable them to communicate with the FSP through a channel they find most effective and convenient; and 

  8. regularly monitor and evaluate whether its staff, representatives and agents are responding to the needs of vulnerable consumers and take appropriate actions to address any poor outcomes or make necessary improvements to ensure vulnerable consumers receive fair and equitable treatment. 
Enhancement of Appendix 1
 
Appendix 1 which sets out Fair Outcomes to Financial Consumers has been enhanced to expand the outcomes in paragraphs (b), (d) and (e) to include vulnerable consumers, and to introduce two new provisions that require a FSP to: (i) have dispute resolution processes that are easily accessible and handle financial consumers’ complaints and claims promptly, fairly and effectively (paragraph (g)); and (ii) not treat vulnerable consumers unfairly or exclude them from essential products and services (paragraph (h)).
 
Enhancement of Appendix 2
 
Appendix 2 which provides an example of a “Treat Client Fairly Charter” has been enhanced to include, among others, commitments to ensure that: (i) customers receive suitable advice and recommendations that take into account their financial needs and circumstances (paragraph 5); (ii) consumers’ complaints and claims are handled in a prompt, fair and effective manner (paragraph 6); and (iii) vulnerable consumers are treated fairly and equitably by the FSP’s staff, representatives and agents (paragraph 7).
 
New Appendix 5: Illustrations of Good Practices in dealing with persons with disabilities
 
As guidance for FSPs, a new Appendix 5 has been introduced to provide 14 examples of good practices that can be taken when dealing with persons with disabilities.
 
Other amendments
 
The examples of good practices and poor practices set out in Appendix 2 of the Superseded Policy Document have been relocated to appear directly below the relevant paragraph of the Revised Policy Document. New examples of such practices have also been added to clarify certain provisions of the Revised Policy Document.
 
Where appropriate, the responsibilities imposed in relation to the staff of a FSP have been extended to the representatives and agents of a FSP under the Revised Policy Document.
 
Comments
 
Most of the amendments introduced under the Revised Policy Document have been adopted from the Exposure Draft of Policy Document on Fair Treatment of Financial Consumers issued by BNM on 28 February 2023. As mentioned in the exposure draft, the requirements thereof are to be incorporated into the Policy Document on Fair Treatment of Financial Consumers. In addition, some new requirements have been added to further enhance the Revised Policy Document.
 
The introduction of specific requirements for dealing with vulnerable consumers and the extension of certain responsibilities to representatives and agents of a FSP have raised the bar as to BNM’s expectations of how FSPs are to treat financial consumers.
 
Article by Sharifah Shafika Alsagoff (Partner) and Hafidah Aman Hashim (Partner) of the Islamic Finance Practice and Lee Ai Hsian (Partner) of the Banking and Finance Practice of Skrine.
 

1 “Senior citizen” refers to an individual aged 60 years and above, as defined by the Government of Malaysia in the MyGovernment Portal under the classification of vulnerable groups.
2 “Perlindungan Tenang” refers to insurance or takaful products approved by BNM that meet the requirements (e.g. affordable, easily accessible to the target segments and provide good protection value) set out in the Policy Document on Perlindungan Tenang (BNM/RH/PD 029-46); and “Perlindungan Tenang partner” refers to an entity other than an intermediary appointed by a licensed person to distribute Perlindungan Tenang products.
3 Footnote 4 at page 5 of the Revised Policy Document.

This alert contains general information only. It does not constitute legal advice nor an expression of legal opinion and should not be relied upon as such. For further information, kindly contact skrine@skrine.com.